Jonathan Taylor Thomas aka "JTT"
I'm pretty sure every girl my age had a crush on JTT at some point. I loved him in Home Improvement, Tom and Huck, Wild America and of course he was the voice of young Simba in the Lion King. Looking back at photos from Tom and Huck, Brad Renfro was way hotter.
I first saw him in Camp Nowhere in 1994. I instantly had a crush and wanted to go to camp. In 2002 he would star in Tuck Everlasting and I was pleased to see that he was aging well. No one wants to see a crush go south in the looks department. He's still acting, most recently being on Nashville.
Even though he's not a Jonathan, I have to mention Devon Sawa.
He was in a ton of 90s movies but my favorite was Now and Then. Devon is still acting and is pretty active on twitter. He actually tweeted back at me one time. If you told twelve year old me that, I would have flipped out.
I'm pretty sure I spent most of my allowance on all of those tween magazines like Bop and TigerBeat so I could hang all the posters on my walls.
As for my first crush on a boy that I actually knew in real life, that would be this kid in the Wild Turkey hat. I can't remember his name so let's just call him Jonathan too. I made sure to sit next to him and wore my best dress.
Note my brother behind us getting ready to do something devious I'm sure.